Update January 25, 2023: SOAR Council complete. I predicted this right back in November, that what was already a Disney-backed majority on the Anaheim Council would appoint Disney-backed Daly aide Norma Kurtz for Avelino’s vacancy. D vs R makes no difference at all any more. I tried to be optimistic and fight for Annemarie Randle-Trejo instead, but it was pretty foreordained. Faessel and the two Natalies held out for Norma, and when those three rejected Annemarie, Ashleigh and Carlos had no problem with the SOAR candidate Norma. If anything Norma was worse than the other SOAR candidate Linda Newby, who was proud of her involvement with Anaheim First and SOAR and promised to only be a “placeholder councilwoman” for 18 months.. while Norma kept quiet about her involvement with Anaheim First and SOAR because she knew it was unpopular. I could write a bunch more but… I’m gonna be real busy the next two days, too busy to blog.
[The two Natalies, at left – Mickey LOVES them!
At right, Norma Kurtz is waiting in the wings,
and Gloria is currently upside-down.]
At the last Council meeting, I congratulated Trevor O’Neil and Gloria Ma’ae for making it possible this year for Disney – ONCE AGAIN – to buy Anaheim’s Council Elections – which Trevor and Gloria accomplished by defeating Dr. Jose Moreno’s Campaign Finance Reform ordinance on July 12. (And once again, I must thank Councilmen Steve Faessel and Avelino Valencia for supporting that ordinance, hall passes or not. It seemed like they both believed in it.)
So, as I also mentioned at Council, it’s ironic that those two, Trevor and Gloria, were the only cabal candidates to be defeated by the voters this month. I can’t presume their defeats had anything to do with their no votes on reform, although maybe they did – in any case what they DID have hanging around their necks that the two Natalies don’t have is a RECORD on Council. So it’s close enough to true!
[From July 12, 2022; updated with x’s.]
So you could say that Trevor and Gloria were collateral damage, or “took one for the team” – the important thing is that, with its brace of Natalies, Disney now has a 4-2 majority. It actually is a little bit sad that what brought Trevor down, what made Pringle throw him under the bus and urge him on to an unwinnable Mayor race, was a couple of rare GOOD votes Trevor made – against a housing project in the place of a popular Serrano St. shopping center, and most importantly against a Holden Senior Living facility Pringle wanted to put in place of a Mormon meeting house.
Like I said, with its new Brace of Natalies Disney has a 4-2 majority, which’ll become 5-2 when they anoint Norma Kurtz to fill the vacancy of upwardly-mobile Avelino! Who is Norma Kurtz? Like Avelino, she is on the staff of outgoing Assemblyman Tom Daly, and I see that Avelino put her on the Public Utilities Commission. Right now she is Daly’s District Director, doing Avelino’s old job. [Update – Duane says I got it backwards, that Norma was District Director BEFORE Avelino.] Yes, when searching for his perfect Council replacement, Avelino simply glanced down the hallway! And after all the work Avelino did helping Natalie Rubalcava beat Al Jabbar, he’d certainly earned the right to dictate his own replacement!
I also see that Norma ran for Anaheim Elementary School Board four years ago, against Moreno ally Mark Lopez, who beat her 62% to 38%. Ah! More Moreno-Valencia proxy battles! This is what the coming decade will look like in the Anaheim flatlands – a perpetual low-intensity war between two types of Democrats – the Moreno-allied populist Democrats vs. the Avelino-allied corporatist Democrats. This is our new world, folks.
But the important thing is that Norma is a Tom Daly person – Tom Daly, the guy who as Mayor in the 1990’s agreed to spend hundreds of millions of OUR money to build Disney a mammoth “Mickey & Friends” parking structure, to rent it out to Disney for a dollar a year, let them keep ALL the profits, and then sign the garage over to Disney when we’re all done paying off that construction bond. Dr. Moreno, as his last act on Council, asked the city attorney for his opinion on whether THAT was a “gift of public funds,” but of course Rob Fabela, knowing what side his bread is buttered on, opined that it was NOT, because some “public benefits” were served in the overall deal. More on that below…
*****
The Public’s Great Disney Disconnect.
Some of us were thinking or hoping that maybe it wouldn’t turn out like this, this time, after all the scandals of May and June. Did the voting public not remember, or care, about the FBI indictments, the forced resignation of Mayor Sidhu, the scuttled Stadium deal, the prison-bound Chamber head? Actually I think they did remember and care about all that – see the defeats of Trevor and Gloria, and the use of those scandals in the Mayor-race propaganda. (The clueless and valueless Lincoln Club even tried to tie Ashleigh in to Sidhu and the scandal!)
I think the public just didn’t associate the scandal with Disney and SOAR, as it was mainly the Stadium swindle that was emphasized in the press. But (how to explain this to voters) what is Anaheim’s problem if not an obedient council on sale to the highest bidder? And that highest bidder is ALWAYS Disney, even if you can’t point at something every single year that they are demanding.
When the FBI reports documented a self-styled “CABAL” running Anaheim, it was not just the disgraced Ament and Flint but also Disney government-relations flack Carrie Nocella who were dictating Council policy and writing Sidhu’s speeches (which he “read so badly.”) It was Disney/SOAR money that BROUGHT you your crooked Mayor Sidhu, as well as ALL the Councilmembers – O’Neil, Faessel, Brandman, Kring – who voted in lockstep to approve the Stadium Swindle. And Disney is the largest member of our discredited cesspool of a Chamber of Commerce.
Every election, I tell voters, “LOOK FOR THE SOAR ON THE BOTTOM” – a foolproof way to tell you that Disney spent big bucks to send you this mailer or show you this TV commercial – more money than any other candidate could possibly put together. It’s just that Anaheim voters haven’t come to think of that being a bad thing yet. When will Anaheim voters be able to choose THEIR OWN representatives? And what more does Disney want from us that they don’t already have?
One clue to that last question may be found in the words, “Disneyland Forward!” – a plan that was vaguely described in the press last year: “Disney officials said it is too early in the process to disclose construction costs but vowed to bring detailed development plans for approval to the Anaheim City Council by 2023.” Well, they are nothing if not insatiable, and as always they’ve got themselves a council that won’t say no to anything!
*****
DI$NEY’$ Fa$cinating Money Experiment!
Well, that’s kind of what it looks like – Disney and SOAR were so comfortable with their keeping council forever, that they decided to conduct a little experiment, or game even, to see exactly how investing varying larger or smaller sums into their candidates would translate into votes. And the answer was surprisingly direct – the more they spent, the more votes they got, and vice-versa! (Is that how simple the people of Anaheim are?)
The person Disney (and Curt Pringle) MOST wanted on the new Council was the blindly obedient Natalie Meeks. So, of the $1.3 MILLION Disney invested in this year’s election, they gave Natalie M the most – a whopping $547K! (And nearly another 100k came from other Disney-allied interests.) And, would you look at that – this translated into Natalie M getting by far the biggest victory in town, beating our friend Hari Lal by 71% to 29%! That money got her over 14,000 votes – at $45.50 a vote! Hope she proves worth it! (Not.)
Disney’s SECOND favorite was the OC Business Council’s Natalie Rubalcava, and they spent the second most helping her beat the honest reformist Al Jabbar – nearly 400K Disney spent on Natalie R, with again allied interests chipping in another 100K for a smooth half million. And that worked too, albeit not as dramatically as with the other Natalie – THIS Natalie whooped her opponent 58% to 42%, still pretty handily!
Then, continuing their little experiment, Disney spent a little less on the uninspiring, appointed Gloria Ma’ae. Possibly also less afraid of Carlos Leon than they were of Al Jabbar, they only chipped in 300K in this race, with allied interests bringing it a bit over 400K. This, for the habitual big spenders, was a sort of brinksmanship, like tipping your chair back a little, and a little more, and then maybe finally falling on the back of your head. With late votes coming in, Carlos has grown his lead over Gloria by… well, still under 100 votes but it ain’t receding. Oh well, no big deal, they still control Council. Sorry Gloria!
Then with poor Trevor they didn’t even try. Doesn’t seem they’re afraid of a Mayor Ashleigh, reformist as she may be. Ditched by Disney and most other special interests (except for the clueless and valueless Lincoln Club), Trevor went down as planned. So let’s recap:
- Natalie M – $547K from Disney, $636K total – got 14,000 votes, won by 71%!
- Natalie R – $380K from Disney, $497 total – got 5400 votes, won by 58%!
- Gloria – $302K from Disney, $416K total – got 4900 votes, losing at 49.63%!
- Trevor – nothing from Disney, $30K total – got 34.4% to Ashleigh’s 43%.
- LESSON LEARNED?
*****
Fred Sigala Jr. is a Deep Thinker.
At the last Council meeting, as I intimated, the City Attorney opined that our giveaway of the Mickey & Friends garage is NOT a “gift of public funds” because of some loosy-goosy definition of what constitutes “public benefits.” Later in the meeting the firefighters’ union, another generous campaign contributor, got THEMSELVES a real sweetheart deal. Friend of the blog and Anaheim Democrats Club VP Fred Sigala (who is also a psychiatric nurse) wrote his thoughts about these developments on Facebook, and the rest of this story is his:
Anaheim’s Beloved relationships are Abusive.
Beloved Disney projects are paid for by the city of Anaheim under the guise of “Economic Development.” Development for our city? No, Disney owns the land on which we paid to build the Mickey and Friends parking structure, has kept all the profits, uses tax revenues meant for us to instead pay the bond, then stands to gain ownership of said structure once the bond is paid off as well. Abuse.
Maybe we should demand Disney stops its abuse by letting us keep our structure and agreeing to lease us their land for $1 a year, same as we’ve done for them and the Angels for decades in order to finally start getting some revenue. Sounds fair to me seeing as we are 2.8 Billion in debt. The legal definition of “economic development” should also be expanded as these Abusers admitted last night they’ve been exploiting loopholes in the language.
A little later our Beloved Firefighters got a record raise, congratulations! But then they also demanded, sorry, “negotiated,” a bonus they’re only supposed get if we can’t give them a standard raise? And we can’t say No because we love them so much and don’t want to be accused of not standing with public safety do we? Did you know victims of abuse are told they shouldn’t allow their partner to treat them poorly just because they love them?
More of the world is learning Anaheim is a victim of Abuse every day. From the story linked below:
“It’s a bit naive to call out a multibillion dollar corporation for seeming greedy. But the extent to which they are so nakedly greedy—so bold and open about it—is unnerving.”
If Disney wants to expand, they should. However, they should do it under the people’s rules. What I propose is, We continuously email and call these Disney Muppets to pressure them into demanding they (Disney) make the Disney cartoons a more permanent presence in the parks.
What’s worse for Anaheim taxpayers? A Disney owned and controlled City Council or a public safety union owned and controlled City Council? What will cost the City treasury more over the long term? A record raise for the fire heroes is just the start.
Nice write up. I live in District 4 and am certain we’ll get another “business Democrat” cypher, just like Football Brandman.
… named Norma Kurtz, my sources tell me.
If I recall correctly, and I might not, Disney does NOT own the land under the parking garage. If it did, it would pay property taxes. Because the land continued to be owned by the City of Anaheim, it is government property on which no taxes are assessed. Once Anaheim gives the parking structure to Disney, it might become assessed — but I’m sure that they may have a way around that, such as continuing to lease the structure from the city for $1/year.
And let it be remembered that in the initial deal, the city was supposed to get a share of each fee to park in Mickey and Friends, as well as a large number of spaces that the city could control and collect fees upon (in lots that are, as I recall, near the Convention Center.) The Council apparently either never tried to collect on what they negotiated for or quietly gave the positive portions of the bargain back to Disney, which could now cite that “course of dealings” with the City as a informing the meaning of the contract, which would have to be something like the mandatory portions disadvantaging Disney were not really mandatory.
I wonder if City Attorney Fabela would consider that to be pursuant to a public benefit as well. Hell, I wonder whether he thinks that letting Disney slant drill into the Anaheim treasury and drink its milkshake would also Hell, at this point I’d like to know what transfer of value to Disney would NOT provide a “public benefit”?
I also wonder whether any resident of Anaheim could ask for the state Attorney General to take a long hard look at Fabela’s shenanigans.
If it’s Anaheim’s land then Disney has to pay Possessory Income Tax.
I commented on Fred’s Facebook post, from which this comes, that in addition “Anaheim’s Abusive relationships are Beloved” — at least by the City’s putative “representatives.”
We are so fortunate to have Disney in our city limits. They are absolutely a giant public company that is driven by delivering a super high quality product and making a profit. They make billions of dollars of investments in their properties around the world and the results are jobs, robust economies, and the growth of thousands of small businesses serving them. God Bless America! What a wonderful “problem” we have in Anaheim. We are busting at the seams with new growth in every sector of our city, not just tourism but every subset of commerce. If not for Walt Disney choosing Anaheim in the early 1950’s, we’d all be living in Vernon.
The issue I WISH you all would focus on is the allocation of the “windfall” of revenues the City of Anaheim gleans from Disney and the Resort year after year. Hundred of millions in taxes and fees could be invested more appropriately by our elected officials. Past “leaders” claimed that “neighborhoods were a top priority”. Those of us that live and work here know that is not the case. Our Police and Fire Departments are short-staffed by dozens of positions and the desperate need to develop training facilities for our public safety teams has no traction. Homeless folks still fill our sidewalks whilst we recently shut down and gutted a new $10mm shelter in East Anaheim so we could park police cars in the building. The problems above are just a few of what the reality of Anaheim is about.
Our past political leadership was weak and not focused on the things that really generate quality of life. Fortunately, with the new mix of our City Council and strong Mayor I truly believe we are going to see some incredible positive change in what was the status quo of the last eight years.
I encourage all those that read Vern’s outstanding work to generate input to our new council in a CONSTRUCTIVE manner. Spend your time at the podium during the marathon “Public Comment” period making problem statements followed by SOLUTIONS to said problems. Stop attacking the elected officials and start attacking the PROBLEMS.
If we all really care about making our city a better place we need to do it WITH the elected leaders, not against them.
Happy Holidays
Bill Taormina
714-308-0220
I wish I had a nickel for every time some stooge told me I have to work with the same system that has caused all the problems in the first place.
Bill Taormina
Agreed. Excellent insight
Seems Bill T has been drinking Disney’s stale kool aid. He knows better than anyone that the resort revenue is committed to repaying resort improvement bonds not to mention outright gifts like the parking garage. Disneyland has been a net burden on residents for a generation.
The East Anaheim shelter was closed because it was an abject failure run by homeless profiteers. The Salvation Army knows how to provide solutions.
Neighborhood needs have been ignored precisely because resort interests have and will continue to control the council. Until corrupt self dealing from the majority stops, I hope the public will continue to speak truth to power.
Good observations. What I had been hoping for during Tait’s brief majority is that an independent auditor be hired to untie the hairball of Resort financing and find out exactly what the Resort does for the residents of the City. Didn’t happen and I’m not sure why it didn’t occur to anybody.
As it is we’re stuck with undemonstrated assertions of people like Kris Murray that the Resort makes Anaheim run. Her numbers were just made up.
Kris Murray?
Goodbye, Kris Murray – we’re gonna miss your sad doll eyes
And your 40-minute soliloquies extolling all the virtues of the Robber Barons waiting to get subsidized.
Goodbye, don’t worry – we never will forget your sighs.
As a point of personal privilege I’d point out that the factoids you repeat about the economy are cherry-picked lies.
Your Operation Home Safe, why it really lit a spark.
Chasing all the homeless off the riverbed, all the way to Maxwell Park!
Don’t feel no hurry to keep swindling us poor chaps!
No, goodbye Kristine Murray, that’s a wrap.
I got chewed out by both Lucille Kring and Assistant City Manager Lilyana Bogdanovich for my insensitivity singing that song at Kris’ last meeting, IN FRONT OF HER HUSBAND AND KIDS, WAHHH! Nobody seemed to appreciate that I’d written her a snazzy new original melody, which I hardly ever do.
You’re supposed to be deferential to the thieves and fools. Decorum, plebes!
Bill Taormina has worked the council to his family’s benefit for decades. See:
https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1992-03-31-mn-339-story.html
The guy literally engaged in the same pay-to-play politics that Disney engages in to our city’s detriment. Cozying up to soon-to-be convicted felon Todd Ament, loving on Carrie Nocella, and all the rest of them.
When Disney/Chamber came after my blog “Save Anaheim.” he promised me he would talk to Todd and Carrie and get all that trash off Cunningham’s blog but he didn’t lift a finger. Instead he laughably asked that I stop exposing the seedy underbelly of the city.
So I say F-you Bill Taormina. Go back to your palatial Newport Coast mansion and stop pretending to give a shit while supporting all the bastards that screw Anaheim residents every year.
This cat seems to have been working both sides of the fence for years. And I seem to recall him providing Lorri Galloway with fake addresses to run for Supervisor in 2010.
I’m thinking Leon, Rubalcava and Kurtz will be a little like Avelino… which at least is better than Sidhu, Brandman, Kring and O’Neil.
I’m gonna be pushing for the Campaign Finance Reform that Trevor and Gloria defeated … even Faessel and Avelino were for it. A little progress at a time…
(PS. Real people using their real names to comment? How quaint and refreshing!)