The Voice of OC has done the heavy lifting — to be distinguished from the heavy pulling — with its seminal story of San Diego Republican Carl “the Wanker” DeMaio being fingered for masturbating into a men’s room sink behind the Council Chambers in 2009. He apparently routinely excused himself to do so after exciting himself with his own impassioned speeches from the dais — coming back to enjoy the rest of the meeting and then later press the flesh.
Our usually staid and respectable cousin publication, though, is not really cut out for the long-term, obsessive — yes, even crazed pursuit of the degree that the story’s release will have stained DeMaio’s reputation. No, that sort of clean-up task is pretty much a job for a spunky publication like the Orange Juice Blog — only because we’re so deeply into media criticism, of course. Will DeMaio manage to rub the story out of the local political headlines — or will he get the shaft?
So: we today introduce a new feature: the Spunky DeMaio Scandal Watch — intended to be weekly but you just never know (unless someone else comes forward to do the reporting, as has not happened with the Dearthwatch — to chronicle two things:
(1) What are the top 20 stories obtained on a Google search over the previous week of the terms “DeMaio” and “San Diego” — including their headlines and where and when they appeared?
(2) What rank does the seminal Voice of OC story get among the search results?
My hypothesis is: the story will get a lot less coverage than it would if DeMaio were a Democrat (and almost infinitely less than if he were a gay Democrat rather than a gay Republican). And that means that everyone complaining (with good reason) about how Filner got away with murder because Democrats didn’t want to talk about his scandal will have another story to complain about — except that this time the refusal to discuss it will be unfolding in real time.
So, after the graphic, let’s head down to Spunky Central for the first installment!

Credit or blame to: http://static.baseballtoaster.com/blogs/u/bronxbanter/2008/1004/0001/2234992576_cbb1c95d76_640.jpg
All right, let’s go. First of all, this week one would expect many of the “DeMaio San Diego” stories not to include this information because they would have come earlier in the week. (The Voice story is only about 48 hours old as I post.) Those stories are linked in orange. This will not be a problem by next weekend.
The point here is to assess how likely it is that a reasonably aware San Diego voter would know about the existence of — or beyond that, the “meat” of — these allegations. If the major media merely, shall we say, “averts their eyes,” then we learn something important: it’s possible to get away with this. Hey, morals evolve, right? That’s something important for DeMaio to know if he becomes Mayor and ever wants to “hand off the gavel” in the middle of a meeting.
My sense is that the non-political reader probably would not yet know about the story. The coverage started with our county’s beloved Voice of OC, but that link doesn’t arise until #55 in my Google search. No, if you were using Google and found out about this, it would most likely be from a Daily Caller story attacking liberals for raising the story. The next highest ranking one would be from the alt-weekly San Diego Reader. And those are the only two stories in the top 10 (actually top 12, given the tie for #2.)
After that, the places one would encounter it would be another Daily Caller story at #11, a Daily Kos story from this afternoon at #15, then stories from rawstory.com and mediaite.com.
At this point, I’d say, the well-informed San Diegan probably thinks that Carl DeMaio has got a great shot to run for Mayor. And if the media keeps on averting its eyes, maybe they’ll be right!
-
Filner backers, DeMaio weigh in – San Diego Union-Tribune
www.utsandiego.com/news/…/demaio-urges-leaders-join-recall-effort/5 days ago – Former City Councilman Carl DeMaio is calling on San Diego’s elected officials, community leaders and top organizations to get behind the effort to recall Mayor … -
News for demaio san diego
2A: Liberals accuse GOP congressional candidate of masturbating at work
Daily Caller - 8 hours ago
Two Democratic members of the San Diego City Council were quoted on the record at VoiceofOc.org making the allegation that DeMaio often polished his family …
2B: Everything you need to know about the San Diego mayoral special election
Washington Post (blog) – 1 day ago
2C: Scandal-plagued San Diego mayor meets with attorneys, city leaders
NBCNews.com (blog) – 4 days ago
-
DeMaio’s men’s room masturbation went unreported | San Diego …
www.sandiegoreader.com/…/demaios-mens-room-masturbation-went-un…2 days ago – The VoiceofOC.org, a nonprofit investigative news agency based in Orange County, tonight (Aug. 22) broke a story that has been hushed up — Republican …
-
Carl DeMaio urges more support of effort to recall San Diego Mayor …
www.10news.com/…/carl-demaio-urges-more-support-of-effort-to-recall…4 days ago – The ex-city councilman who lost the San Diego mayor’s race to Bob Filner last year called Monday on area politicians to get behind a recall effort in a tangible …
-
DeMaio might run for San Diego mayor – 10News
www.10news.com/news/…/carl-demaio-might-run-for-mayor-in-san-die…1 day ago – Carl DeMaio might run for mayor, according to his campaign manager. A meeting is planned to “access the options.”. Team 10 investigations expose …
-
Carl DeMaio (carldemaio) on Twitter
https://twitter.com/carldemaio3 days ago – @carldemaio now working to recall #sandiego Mayor Bob #filner.Demaio collecting signatures n La Jolla now. #10news pic.twitter.com/TkGyLb2UJv.
-
Carl DeMaio mulls run for San Diego mayor instead of Congress …
washingtonexaminer.com/carl-demaio-mulls…san–diego…/2534650?…1 day ago – Last year, Carl DeMaio nearly bested Bob Filner in the race to be the mayor of San Diego. Now, with Filner resigning amidst serious allegations of sexual …
-
San Diego 6 – Will We Soon See Mayor Carl DeMaio?
www.sandiego6.com/…/will-we-soon-see-mayor-carl-demaio–201308231 day ago – $30.00 for $145.00. at Simply Scentual. – San Diego – Limited quantity. Simply Scentual. $30 for Your Choice of One of Five Facials …
-
DeMaio Considers Bid for Mayor After Bob Filner’s Resignation | At …
atr.rollcall.com/demaio-considers-bid-for-mayor-after-bob-filners-resign…21 hours ago – In a Friday evening statement from his House campaign, DeMaio praised Filner’s departure. “With Bob Filner’s resignation, San Diego has been given a fresh …
-
Congressional candidate Carl DeMaio accused of masturbating at …
dailycaller.com/…/liberals-accuse-gop-congressional-candidate-of-mastur…1 day ago – Two Democratic members of the San Diego City Council were quoted on the record at VoiceofOc.org making the allegation that DeMaio often polished his family …
-
DeMaio to Help Collect Signatures to Recall Filner – Challenges …
carldemaio.com/…/demaio-help-collect-signatures-recall-filner-challenge…6 days ago – San Diego – Saying that removing Bob Filner from the Mayor’s Office is a fundamental “test of leadership,” Carl DeMaio today issued a challenge to elected …
-
Ex-councilman DeMaio will help suppport voter recall effort – San …
www.examiner.com/…/ex-councilman-demaio-will-help-suppport-voter-…4 days ago – Last November, Filner gained 52 percent of the vote to defeat DeMaio in a runoff election for San Diego City Mayor, according to KOGO, and over at Yahoo it is …
-
DeMaio Asks Politicians Get Behind Mayor Bob Filner’s Recall …
lajolla.patch.com/…/demaio-asks-politicians-get-behind-mayor-bob-filne…5 days ago – Carl DeMaio, a former San Diego Councilman, asked local council members and legislators to sign petitions to recall Filner, help collect signatures an.
-
Daily Kos: Bob Filner’s 2012 Republican opponent Carl DeMaio …
www.dailykos.com/…/-Bob-Filner-s-2012-Republican-opponent-Carl-De…5 hours ago – Now, The Voice of OC, an Orange County-based website, is reporting that Carl DeMaio, who was Filner’s Republican opponent in the 2012 San Diego mayoral
… You visited this page on 8/24/13. -
San Diego Republican accused of openly masturbating in men’s …
www.rawstory.com/…/san–diego-republican-accused-of-openly-masturba…3 hours ago – According to the San Diego Reader, Republican Carl DeMaio was accused of the lascivious acts in 2009 and never answered the charges, but rather had the …
-
Everything you need to know about the San Diego mayoral special …
www.washingtonpost.com/…/bob-filners-resignation-would-trigger-a-spe…2 days ago – Embattled San Diego Mayor Bob Filner (D) will reportedly resign as part of a settlement of a … Former city councilman Carl DeMaio: Filner defeated DeMaio in a …
-
Cover Story — DeMaio vs. Filner, San Diego Metro Magazine
www.sandiegometro.com/2012/07/cover-story-—-men-who-rock/3 days ago – DeMAIO vs. FILNER By eschewing the traditional moderates, San Diegans have set up a rare partisan battle in the November mayor election By Liam D.
-
DeMaio Urges Politicians To Aid In Filner Recall Effort – Yahoo! News
news.yahoo.com/…/demaio-urges-politicians-aid-fil…
5 days agoSupporters of Mayor Bob Filner rallied in front of city hall Monday while Carl Demaio, who ran for mayor of San …
-
San Diego Mayoral Candidate Accused of Masturbating in City Hall …
www.mediaite.com/…/guess-what-sex-act-the-gop-candidate-to-replace-b…54 mins ago – Sex scandal appears to be breeding sex scandal in San Diego, as CarlDeMaio, a potential Republican candidate to replace now ex-Mayor Bob Filner, has …
Officials Concerned: “There may be something in the water.” | The …
With Filner Reportedly Out What’s Next for San Diego? :: Fox&Hounds
Filner Was Not the Only SD Mayoral Candidate With Alleged Sex …
2 days ago – U.S. House candidate and former San Diego City Councilman CarlDeMaio, Filner’s opponent in last fall’s mayoral election, would masturbate in a bathroom …
You’re aware, aren’t you, that this article was footed with an ad saying “CLICK HERE TO VIEW YOUR ARREST RECORD NOW”?
Have they targeted the ads or what?
OK, I’m impressed!
I didn’t get that ad either.
Now I get one with Shell Oil talking about “energy solutions.” I’d rather be invited to view my arrest record.
Just happen to be in San Diego county this weekend, and grabbed up a copy of the Union Tribune. Big front page story about the six front-runners for Mayor, including De Maio. Paragraph upon paragraph about DeMaio but nothing about this. Interestingly, four of the six candidates are gay (and a fifth, Nathan Fletcher, broke with the GOP by sticking up for The Gay.) An equal and opposite reaction to FILNER?
You notice the detail in Rex Dalton’s Voice of OC story where he couldn’t get it published down here in SD, and had to come up to Norberto’s place to do it? The Union Tribune, bought 20 months ago by a local conservative tycoon, seems to be in the bag for DeMaio. From Wikipedia (surprisingly not scrubbed) :
When Manchester and business partner John Lynch took ownership in 2011, they were open about their desire to use the newspaper to “promote their agenda of downtown development and politically conservative causes”,[20] with Lynch stating on KPBS radio that he and Manchester “wanted to be cheerleaders for all that is good in San Diego.”[21] Lynch expanded on this position in 2012, saying “We make no apologies. We are doing what a newspaper ought to do, which is to take positions. We are very consistent — pro-conservative, pro-business, pro-military — and we are trying to make a newspaper that gets people excited about this city and its future.”[22]
This open promotion of certain viewpoints has resulted in criticism from journalism professors and other newspaper editors, who worry that negative news about topics such as the military and business might not be covered.[23] Dean Nelson, director of the journalism program at Point Loma Nazarene University, argued, “Now if you’re saying we’re going to be the cheerleaders of the military, why would you report on this guy that’s taking bribes?… Where’s the cheerleading there?” a reference to the Union-Tribune’s Pulitzer Prize winning coverage of the Duke Cunningham bribery scandal.[24] A New York Times writer added, “There is a growing worry that the falling value and failing business models of many American newspapers could lead to a situation where moneyed interests buy papers and use them to prosecute a political and commercial agenda. That future appears to have arrived in San Diego.”[22]
Lynch says, “We totally respect the journalistic integrity of our paper and there is a clear line of demarcation between our editorials and our news. Our editor, Jeff Light, calls the shots.” However, in November 2011 Lynch told the sports editor that the sports pages should advocate for a new football stadium; when a longtime sportswriter wrote skeptically about the idea, he was fired.[22]
In January 2012, two months after Manchester bought the U-T, the paper featured a front -page proposal for downtown redevelopment, to include a downtown football stadium and an expansion of the San Diego Convention Center.[25] Both properties are adjacent to hotels that Manchester owns.[26]
In September 2012, Investigative Newsource reporter Brooke Williams obtained articles that claimed Lynch “threatened” Port Commissioner Scott Peters, who was running for Congress, “with a newspaper campaign to dismantle the Unified Port of San Diego.” In e-mails obtained by Williams, Lynch was quoted as indicating that if the Dole Food Company obtained a long term contract, that the Port’s independence governance would be questioned in editorial coverage. Williams said the effort showed “the extent to which the newspaper’s new owners will go to push their vision for a football stadium on the Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal,”[27]
In October 2012, a poll was taken by the U-T concerning the mayoral race which excluded “Employees of a newspaper, television / radio station, marketing / public opinion research company or the city of San Diego—or who live with someone employed in one of those fields.” This poll showed that mayoral candidate Carl DeMaio polled significantly higher than other polls which did not exclude those respondents, which political researchers charged introduced bias into the poll.[28]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U-T_San_Diego
Googled, it’s not gonna be a secret much longer, even behind the San Diego Curtain – Rex’s story has hit Mediaite and Huffpo! (results 3 and 5)
http://www.mediaite.com/online/guess-what-sex-act-the-gop-candidate-to-replace-bob-filner-is-accused-of/
http://www.mediaite.com/online/guess-what-sex-act-the-gop-candidate-to-replace-bob-filner-is-accused-of/
and result #7 from the San Diego Reader, the SD equivalent of the OC Weekly! http://www.sandiegoreader.com/weblogs/news-ticker/2013/aug/22/demaios-mens-room-masturbation-went-unreported/
And all these sources had to credit the Voice of OC! Yay…
Now you see why I’m making this a series!
Coming to the party since last time, and sharing the #3 spot (for “News”) with the already mentioned report from mediaite.com::
The New York Post: http://www.nypost.com/p/news/national/potential_successor_openly_masturbating_AntiSiplAN5PgeY03tKicO
Huffington Post:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/08/25/carl-demaio-bob-filner_n_3813703.html
The Union-Tribune (and OC/LB Register) continue to avert their eyes.
Addendum: to address a theme that may be arising in defense of DeMaio — I’m glad that he came out of the closet. I just wish that he hadn’t come out of the stall.
No new heavy hitters join in the distribution of the charges against DeMaio today, but a very heavy hitter — NBC San Diego — gives DeMaio the chance to respond.
http://www.nbcsandiego.com/news/politics/Carl-DeMaio-Allegations-Masturbation-Bathroom-City-Hall-Voice-of-OC-221379541.html
The embed with the video of the interview with a very angry DeMaio didn’t work — so here’s the link instead.
Selected nuggets from the NBC story:
So that’s where things stand. We’ll continue monitoring to see whether Hueso backs away from the allegation or, on the other hand, whether DeMaio comes clean.
Possibly the most important contribution yet to this discourse:
KARMA FOR DEMAIO!!!!!! REPUBLICANS SET UP BOB FILNER WITH SEX SCANDAL!!!! NOW KARMA FOR DEMAIO AND THOSE SLEAZY ARROGANT REPUBS!!!!! NO ONE VOTES REPUBLICAN!!!! FROM CRIMINAL NIXON / WATERGATE TO DEMENTIA HEAD REAGAN/ IRAN CONTRA TO LIVING ABORTION BUSH/ IRAQ!!!!!! CRIMINAL REPUBLICANS STEAL ELECTIONS IMPEACH PRESIDENTS RECALL ENEMIES AND REDISTRICT TO FORCE THEIR JOHN BIRCH PSYCHOSES .ON AMERICA ALL THE WHILE HIDING BEHIND THE FLAG OR BIBLE!!!!!!!!