Don’t expect SoCal water buffalos to defy Trump on Climate Change.

Metropolitan Water District of Southern California and member agencies
are backsliding on their commitment to science-based climate adaptation.
Part 3

by John Earl, Nov. 9, 2026; cross-posted from SoCal Water Wars

Following the excitement over America’s “blue tsunami” and the Democratic Party old guard’s promises to investigate the Trump family and its oligarch allies for countless crimes and moral outrages against our democratic republic and humanity, while continuing to reject Medicare for All or, God forbid, impeachment of The Fascist Beast (no hyperbole intended), the inner workings of our regional and local water agencies might seem trivial and irrelevant.

The Goatfürher at Burning Hills, California©️2025 Martha Previte

But the only people who would think that are the countless millions of public citizens who have never paid much attention to what goes on at their local and regional water districts save for looking at a few news stories from corporate media every year. What little you do know about them is most likely due to corporate-style branding strategies and the media’s largely uncritical acceptance of the resulting self-serving profiles.

What most Americans do know is that Donald Trump, severely wounded by the sweeping rejection of his policies in the mid-term elections, intends to fight back with a rejuvenated fascist agenda led by his new chief of staff, Stephen Miller.

Meanwhile, the the Democratic Party’s counterplan will be determined by its fossilized leadership: U.S. Senator Chuck Schumer and House member Hakeem Jeffries, two of the most unpopular AIPAC-supported and corporate-toadying politicians in the nation.

If the Democratic Party can’t be trusted to effectively fight the MAGA-fascist agenda, don’t bet on the water buffalos sitting on your local and regional water-district boards to do so, especially when it comes to seriously integrating climate-science with water-management policies.

MWDOC board meeting. Photo SoCal Water Wars

As I previously reported, the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California (MWD) Board of Directors, responding to concerns expressed by members representing the Municipal Water District of Orange County (MWDOC), voted to stall an existential staff-proposal to update the District’s Administrative Code—an update meant to ensure that future water-management decisions would be guided by the “best available climate science.”

§4212. Climate Adaptation:

It shall be the policy of the District to consider climate risks and integrate climate adaptation and risk reduction strategies into its programs, policies, planning, and operations. The District will utilize the best available climate science and real-world conditions to evaluate risks and proposed investments to meet regional water needs.

At the Sept. 14 meeting of MWD’s One Water and Adaptation Committee, Elizabeth Crosson, MWD’s chief climate officer, proposed aligning the Admin Code with the District’s flagship Climate Adaptation Management Plan for Water (CAMP4W), which the board approved with fanfare twice—first in 2023 and again in 2025 in its final form (for background, see MWD’s climate-science delay).

On Sept. 14, the One Water committee conducted what Board Chair Adán Ortega later described as a “robust conversation” on the proposed code update. The discussion centered on exchanges among Ortega, MWDOC-appointed directors Karl Seckel, Randall Crane, Dennis Erdman; and General Manager Shivaji Deshmukh. Also notably contributing to the discussion was non-committee member Nancy Sutley, the City of Los Angeles’s appointee to the MWD board.

Ms. Crosson made her presentation, summarizing the need for MWD to align its Administrative Code with the climate-adaptation framework embedded in CAMP4W, the plan the board has already adopted. In practice, that means keeping the code consistent with the latest and best climate science.

Dennis Erdman, MWDOC’s appointee, started the conversation by asking Crosson to elaborate on “best climate science.”

Crosson noted that climate science evolves, alluding to the standard currently guiding CAMP4W—RCP 8.5—which is now considered outdated by climate scientists. It is important “that as we conduct our long-term planning, that we’re using the best available information out there,” she explained.

She further stated:

“Our team, based on the fact that there are some new projections approved and utilized by climate scientists and climate professionals are relooking at also using the best available science. And I think it’s an important commitment that we make that we continue to adapt and evolve based on what’s a very dynamic area of research.”

Erdman responded that, “Based on the fact that we’re now looking at RCP 8.5,” he wanted to know what the implications of that might be for CAMP4W. “Accordingly, I would like to make a motion to table this item until we have that information in front of us,” he declared.

In other words, Erdman sought information from staff on the implications of proceeding with water-management planning under the guidance of outdated science. Plus, he wanted to “table” the proposed Admin code update, which under parliamentary rules means burying it indefinitely.

Crosson clarified that the proposed amendment didn’t mention RCP 8.5, indicating that it was only tangentially related to codifying the board’s previously approved decision to use the best available climate-adaptation science.

Irritated by Crosson’s contrary response, Erdman replied, “But it is integral to the Climate Adaption Master Plan for Water that we now have as a board accepted document,” though he never explained why that would justify rejecting the amendment and stalling MWD’s commitment to adhere to the best science.

Why would MWD hinder implementation of its own CAMP4W policy by refusing to follow up to date climate science? More broadly, why would any public agency responsible for protecting public health and welfare reject the best available science in carrying out its duties?

Scientific research is inherently fluid in an ever-changing world. The board did not approve any particular climate study or model; rather, it approved a commitment to use the “best available” climate science as that science evolves.

Crosson argued that the proposed Administrative Code amendment was fully consistent with that commitment. In fact, she said, it was “a great example of how we’re adaptively managing” the CAMP4W process mandated by the board in 2025.

The amendment, she explained more to the point, is “actually being very clear that [at] your direction we continue to use the best available science; if that means that 8.5 needs to be updated, then it should be updated.”

Still not persuaded, Randall Crane, another MWDOC appointee to the MWD board and a member of the One Water committee, seconded Erdman’s motion. Then, another MWDOC appointee, Karl Seckel, who was acting chair of the One Water Committee for the day, opened the meeting for further discussion.

MWD Board Chair Adán Ortega, not a member of the committee, then accused the amendment’s opponents of “trying to bury our head in the sand” about dealing with the “worse case scenario” posed by increasingly informed and dire predictions of evolving climate science. They were doing so, he implied, to shield favored water-management schemes from scrutiny.

Recent comments by directors at public meetings of MWD and its member-agency San Diego County Water Authority reveal a strong preference for multibillion-dollar projects such as the Delta Conveyance Project (Governor Newsom’s one-tunnel dream), Sites Reservoir, and interstate transfers of ocean-desalinated water through the SDCWA, alongside an aggressive expansion of large-scale desalination projects along the California coast.

In rebuttal, Seckel could barely contain himself…

READ THE REST AT SOCAL WATER WARS!!

Seckel is ours.

About Surf City Voice

John Earl is the editor of SoCal Water Wars (previously Surf City Voice.) Frequent contributor Debbie Cook, a former Huntington Beach Mayor, is board president of the Post Carbon Institute.