Arizona Passes nation’s toughest illegal immigrant law

Picture courtesy of the New York Daily News

Over several years the Arizona Legislature has passed legislation that categorized the presence of an illegal person in Arizona as trespassing, making that a misdemeanor crime that law enforcement authorities would be expected to enforce. When the legislation reached the Governor, it was vetoed. But maybe not this time.

The gubernatorial vetoes were by then Democratic Governor Janet Napolitano, who is now President Obama’s Secretary of Homeland Security. This year things are different. Republican Governor Jan Brewer, who is running for re-election, is expected by many to sign the legislation.

According to press accounts the law makes it a misdemeanor to not have proper documentation papers and requires peace officers to determine a person’s immigration status if the officer has reasonable suspicion. Cities and counties are prohibited from having policies that conflict with this law, thereby thwarting any thought by a municipality of becoming a sanctuary.

The ACLU has already vowed to sue for various reasons, including that this new law will lead to profiling people with brown skin and/or accents. Perhaps the differing views on this legislation are best illustrated by the quotes of two Arizona state legislators appearing in an April 14 Los Angeles Times story:

“Illegal immigration brings crime, kidnapping, drugs-drains our government services. Nobody can stand on the sidelines and not take part in this battle.” – Republican John Kavanagh.

“This bill, whether we intend it or not, terrorizes the people we profit from.” – Democrat Tom Chabin.

People on both sides of this issue doubt that the arguments about this legislation are over.


About Over But Not Out

A retired Orange County employee, and moderate Republican. The editor seriously does not know OBNO's identity as did not the former editor, but his point of view is obviously interesting and valued.