Normal people, normal parents, don’t lose sleep worrying about their kids finding out at school that gay and trans people exist and have rights. No matter what crazy unverified scare-stories the culture warriors tell them.
Normal people, normal parents, don’t see a big problem with their kids being taught that some bad things happened in our nation’s history, that a lot of bad things happened to dark people and some bad things were done by some white people. And this is not the dread “Critical Race Theory,” which is only taught to college students who are interested in it. These normal parents aren’t too keen on books being banned either.
And the fact that there were mask mandates and school closures a few years ago during our biggest pandemic outbreak in a century is something normal parents hardly think about any more, and mostly didn’t have a big problem with at the time, let alone blame it on some sinister government conspiracy. They’re just glad they and their kids survived those years.
But those are the main, burning issues to the many Culture Warriors who got elected in low-turnout School Board elections in recent years, and they have been busy making spectacles of themselves and their school districts ever since. Engrossed in their crusades, most of these Culture Warriors have never before shown any interest or had any experience in EDUCATION. And as they are disbelievers in government, blowing public money on doomed lawsuits and other fools’ errands, losing state funding, and breaking the law, are NO BIG DEAL to them.
So it’s good to see, from Temecula to Orange and doubtless many other places, the normal people and parents (of all political Parties) rising up to take back their school boards. In the name of sanity, good education, and fiscal responsibility. Let’s start with this Politico piece that came out last week…
Ah, beautiful Temecula, a mere 50 miles inland from the OC! Home to so many good people, and stomping grounds of evangelical pastor Tim Thompson of neighboring Murietta’s “412 Church,” who’s been crying out in the wilderness for years that “government-ran [sic] schools are Satan’s Playground!” When no other Southern California venue would host the traitorous Marjorie Taylor Greene, it was Pastor Tim’s 412 Church that welcomed her.
Fervently opposed to the separation of church and state, sickened unto death at the very thought of sex education… but these pathologies were mere co-morbidities waiting to be exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic. In 2020 Pastor Tim got himself arrested in Sacramento protesting lockdowns, and later when Temecula’s Board of Education wouldn’t pass his anti-masking resolution, he vowed to have them replaced.
Which he accomplished through his church, his money, his radio show “Our Watch,” and his Inland Empire Family PAC, getting three Culture Warriors NARROWLY ELECTED last year in a low-turnout election. (And shame on Normal People for not taking school boards seriously and not “voting down-ballot.” We can only hope they’re learning.)
First thing this new Board majority did was pass a resolution condemning the dread “Critical Race Theory,” which never existed in Temecula schools, but sure got them invited onto Fox and Friends! Which encouraged them to also spend district money hiring an outside consultant just to preach, pointlessly, against CRT! Emboldened, they next rejected a social-studies curriculum that included a half-page bio of Harvey Milk, calling the martyred gay civil-rights hero a “pedophile.” Normal people started to get upset, and a civil rights complaint was filed against the board.
But the final straw was when, following the lead of the nearby Orange USD (which we’ll look at below), they fired the district’s very popular and successful Superintendent, for no reason. And a recall movement was born. From Politico:
“We don’t want culture wars. We don’t want Fox News appearances,” Temecula’s Alex Douvas, a parent of two kids in the district who previously worked for two Republican congressmembers in Orange County, told the board recently. “Our schools are not ideological battlegrounds. They’re not platforms for religious evangelism. These are institutions for learning and growth.”
The religious right saw an opening to jump into the parental rights movement amid intense backlash about pandemic-era school closures and mask mandates. But those policies have all but disappeared in schools, and it’s proving harder to sustain that level of outrage over teachings on race and gender. The effort to ban certain books and challenge curriculum has split Republicans and polled poorly with independent voters nationally.
MEANWHILE HERE IN ORANGE…
The Politico piece on Temecula briefly refers to the controversies over at nearby Orange USD, and the parallels are striking – three-member Culture Warrior majorities that BARELY won in low-turnout votes. Boards that outraged the public and blew wads of money firing popular successful Superintendents for no reason. And notably, both takeovers were engineered by local evangelical preachers. Just as Pastor Tim Thompson can boast of getting a Culture Warrior majority in Temecula, in Orange (and Anaheim Hills) we have Chino megachurch pastor Jack Hibbs to thank for the current unhingedness.
The pastor of Calvary Chapel Chino Hills, with even more radio coverage than Thompson with his “Real Life” program, Jack Hibbs has always been especially concerned that the existence of homosexuality is a sure sign of the End Times – because just think – those sodomites don’t procreate! So it could NOT have been in existence until just recently or humanity would already have perished, can’t you see? He illustrates this theory with films of ELKS mating, particularly focusing on the phenomenon of the biggest male elk beating up the smaller male elks, and then impregnating all the females – apparently an invaluable object lesson for us humans!
You may say to yourselves, can’t these evangelical pastors be content just telling their vast congregations how to live, and keep their hands off our public school boards? Pero NO. Hibbs looked 30 miles southwest, and saw in OUSD, which already had two Culture Warriors on board (Rick Ledesma & John Ortega), a school board ripe for the plucking. He’d just need to get ONE MORE elected.
And he found his candidate in “parents’ rights advocate” Madison Miner. History in the district? Well, 22 years ago when Fred “God Hates Fags” Phelps’ Westboro Baptist Church came to protest against OUSD’s gay-straight alliance, Madison’s parents Fran and Bill Klovstad stood side-by-side with them. Not falling far from the tree, Madison’s biggest nightmares are about “gender ideologies,” and the supposed inability of parents to opt their kids out of sex ed – that’s what she means by the catchphrase “parents’ rights.” (Actually, under California education code, parents can opt kids out of a lot of sex ed, but they can’t opt them out of lessons about gender, gender identity, and sexual orientation. But that’s not up to local school boards.)
Like most of these Culture Warriors taking over our public school boards, Madison sends her own kids to a private charter school, OC Classical Academy, which is directed by extremist Dr. Stefan Bean. Dr. Bean ran last year against incumbent OC Superintendent of Education Al Mijares, a moderate Republican, and Mijares clobbered him – Bean’s outrageous claim that public schools teach “inappropriate sexual matters” to kindergarteners, which he could never substantiate, was too extreme for the OC Register, which endorsed Mijares.
But Madison made it, barely squeezing by with a 111-vote margin, and the new OUSD majority got right to work “making a laughingstock of the district.” First thing they did (and the most controversial and wasteful so far) was to fire their longtime and well-regarded Superintendent Gunn Marie Hansen. They did this at a hastily-convened “special meeting” in January, they GAVE NO REASON, and Hansen and her thousands of supporters in the district were blindsided. Weird. Not long before, Board President Ledesma had raved (accurately) about Hansen:
“Her leadership team delivered a positive audit report to continue the stellar OUSD fiscal reputation. Dr. Hansen is a highly regarded visionary who will take OUSD to the next level. She is dedicated to the Orange community, committed long-term, and the Board of Education has great confidence in her abilities.”
– Board Chairman Rick Ledesma, who shortly later voted to fire Hansen for no cause.
What happened since then, Rick? Are you following someone else’s orders now? This decision not only pissed off thousands of Hansen’s admirers, it’s cost the district a million dollars so far. The Board hired a replacement, some guy from Idaho, who stayed for two weeks, couldn’t handle the dysfunction, and hightailed it back to Idaho – THAT cost the district $75,000, and the district STILL doesn’t have a Superintendent. And these clowns ran on “cutting wasteful spending.” Dr. Hansen is fine, the Westminster School District snatched her right up.
This piece is getting long enough, but there are plenty of more reasons that voters in the district are launching a recall of Ledesma and Miner, which you can read here; if you live in that district you should sign up as well. Signatures are being gathered now. The district includes Orange, Villa Park, Anaheim Hills, Silverado, and parts of Garden Grove and Santa Ana.
(Miner/Ledesma ally John Ortega has his own ethical problems, but he is up for re-election next year, so somebody should run against him and beat him in ’24. As things SHOULD work when voters are paying attention.)
Recalls are a drastic measure, and there’s such a thing as Recall Fatigue these days, but this blog supports the recall of Ledesma and Miner as timely and necessary. But over the long haul, the public needs to start taking school board races more seriously. And candidates who really care about quality education need to make it clear how they differ from the Culture Warriors they are running against, and what those people’s innocuous slogans (like “parents’ rights,” which everybody supports) really signify. For, to paraphrase that great father of conservatism Edmund Burke,
“The only thing necessary for madness to triumph is for normal people to do nothing.”
You may want to take notice of the likes of folks in line with Assemblymember Bilal Essayli (R-Corona) who are taking up portions of the abnormal parents fight in the halls of the California legislature. They are provoking confrontations between parents and school boards in the IE and elsewhere on culture war issues. Bilal Essayli has been a Republican rabble rouser for sometime. See also Harmeet Dhillon. They work in tandem.
https://edsource.org/2023/battle-over-transgender-student-privacy-isnt-over-bills-author-says/689039?amp=1
https://calmatters.org/justice/2020/05/california-shutdown-lawsuits-newsom-dhillon-coronavirus-shelter-in-place-executive-orders/
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2020/aug/4/martinez-california-couple-painting-over-black-liv/
My understanding is that Miner outspent her opponent last year 20 to 1, with bundles of money coming from the Hillsdale charter school network funneled through the Barkes and others in the Orange County Board of Education.
Extremists with the same Christian Nationalist worldview and charter money funneled through the OCBE have taken control of the PYLUSD and have wasted mountains of money by releasing administrators with records of success and replacing them with outsiders aligned with their agenda.
Yep that’s absolutely true. But I think it’s the other way around as Leandra Blades and Shawn Youngblood helped get Miner into office. PYLUSD has been fighting this for years and it’s basically a trio of Klanned Karenhood Moms who direct the republican jesus fanclub here
Racist. “Karenhood”. Wow! You show your ass sir.
You sir apparently haven’t seen black and brown and male Karens, in real life or on social media. For shame your racist ass is showing.
I’m sorry “Ron” — I don’t like the term “Karen” (out of respect more the many wonderful women named Karen I have known), but “Klanned Karenhood” was pretty funny.
But we have a bigger problem here, which is that from the avatars (which I don’t think Vern sees), you’re the same person as the person to whom you’re responding. I will investigate.
Yes I see the avatars, I just don’t find them as probative of malfeasance as you seem to. Last time it was Hector Robles and Bryan Kaye, two real people we know, writing from different IPs, who shared the same avatar. I know Miguel too, and he wouldn’t say some stupid shit to himself.
We’ve apparently hit the point of recycling avatars. That’s what suddenly increases their lack of probitiveness.
Yeah figured. Where are those avatar manufacturers? Are they on strike?
They come with the package. I suspect that they have 1000 (or however many) of them pre-packaged and we’ve just recently crossed into #1001.
They are two more radical freaks to get rid of
So you are in favor of all of the curricula materials that have been found in our schools and libraries? I went, I saw and I could not share in social media platforms. The specific churches you mentioned may not be my cup of tea but I’m thankful that some are speaking out. Sexually explicit instructions and race-shaming exercises are NOT “normal” educational topics and I don’t consider those who embrace them as @normal folks either. In the contrary, they are a distraction from the wealth of knowledge students need to amass to be successful in higher education, careers, communication and life skills.
The history of this country includes the enslavement of Black people. That is a fact. The Constitution of the United States when it was first written referred to Black people as 3/5 of a person. That was not remedied until the Union won the Civil War over the Confederates. You seem to want to ignore all the facts of history and to pretend that learning such would hurt the feelings of white children. Shielding children from unpleasant things and uncomfortable feelings does them no good, it causes them harm. They will not grow up to be functional adults.
And Americans should feel some shame that such inhumane practices were considered normal, and continue to this day, not as the enslavement of Black bodies, but as oppression in various forms. Jim Crow laws have never completely been overcome in many states in America, and in fact are getting strengthened due to recent SCOTUS decisions. We don’t learn from our mistakes if we deny we ever make them.
Being an adult means one understands that there is discomfort in life and being a good parent means you prepare your children to cope in a healthy way with them. Burying your head in the sand so only your rear end is exposed is not healthy.
Thank you for the thorough piece. I’ve been waiting for Madison Klovstad Miner’s parents’ anti-LGBTQ activism to be given some attention. The apple really doesn’t fall far from the tree here.
Disgusted by her ballot statement lies, the lies she and her campaign spread about her opponent, lies she’s told about sex ed in schools, parental rights, her hot (illegal) take on segregating special ed students because some teachers told her they found IEP accommodations difficult and “distracting.”
The damage she’s done with her three bought-and-paid-for cronies on the OUSD board in firing our superintendent without notice, without cause & without a plan is fiscal negligence and will be far reaching as the chaos around that move shows no end in sight.
We’ve lost 25% of our principals since January when they fired the superintendent. It’s gotten so bold as to Moner actively recruiting families away from the district she’s sworn to represent, sending them to her own non-OUSD “classical” school of choice. Recall Recall Recall.
Please provide at least five examples of books you saw and teachers who have done the things that you allege. Be specific if you are going to defame the highly successful educational programs in Orange County.
Specifically which books did you see? Did you report them to anyone?
More re Harmeet Dhillon. On point re wiping out some school boards.
https://twitter.com/pnjaban/status/1493815252206567425?lang=en
https://calmatters.org/politics/2022/08/california-republicans-school-board-races/
Dhillon leads center for American liberty.
https://amp.sacbee.com/news/politics-government/capitol-alert/article271295532.html
https://www.foxnews.com/media/california-mom-teachers-daughter-transgender-education-school.amp
https://time.com/6249905/harmeet-dhillon-rnc-chair-ronna-mcdaniel/
Please summarize the links
What a completely shit, fever-dream article.
Seriously, you’re afraid to publish that opinion under your own name? Snowflake!
Vern, As you know, we view things quite differently. I disagree with a great deal of your writing here.
As usual, you are preaching only to your choir.
BTW – normal parents stand up for their children and raise them as they see fit and.should not have to HAVE them raised by a public or government entity that forces SOCIAL curriculum that differs from their standards.
That is why I support school vouchers, school choice, charter schools and homeschooling.
Public Education Sucks.
Judging from your comments…you probably missed a lot of school
Actually Bill and I both went to Mater Dei… he was guitarist in my punk rock band the Pedestrians back around 1980. He just turned out a lot more conservative than me.
I don’t think most of his points here negate most of my points here though. I wasn’t saying nothin bad about “choice” and charters.
Perversion and lies has no limits with the left and they hide behind a fake banner of decency as they continue to destroy the fabric of a nation.
Haha, good one.
Radicals on both sides are equally as dangerous just in different ways. They both want to control and control of the masses or a good portion of it. It’s a both sides of the aisle thing. Progressives are trying to kill me with among other things their fake anti-hate rhetoric and fake protected class nonsense and climate/clean energy activism. Yada yada yada.
Yeah well in the context of this article we’re not talking about radicals on the left. They’re not a problem on school boards these days, at least anywhere near where I live.
Wrong.
There ya go again.
https://www.dailybulletin.com/2023/07/20/state-schools-chief-tony-thurmond-booted-from-chino-valley-school-board-meeting/amp/
Temecula boiling.
https://www.cbsnews.com/amp/losangeles/news/gov-newsom-fines-temecula-valley-school-board-1-5-for-rejecting-new-curriculum/
https://www.pressenterprise.com/2023/07/20/temecula-school-board-to-vote-again-on-rejected-curriculum/amp/
Neshanian, who has been put on time out for baselessly calling people racist, keeps sending in updates to this story, and sure enough, as he says, Temecula is on fire!
Newsom reacts to Temecula by pushing new law https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-07-19/newsoms-push-for-textbook-regulation-defies-current-state-law
Temecula will take another bite at the apple, the apple of burying “pedophile” Milk. Not sure why it’ll be any different next time… https://www.pressenterprise.com/2023/07/20/temecula-school-board-to-vote-again-on-rejected-curriculum/amp/
And not to be outdone, neighboring Chino Hills School Board votes to inform parents if their kid is veering toward trans. Huge dangerous civil rights and safety problem. To make the story more colorful, distinguished State Education Superintendent Thurmond was down here, to remonstrate with both these boards over their craziness, and they kicked him out (on the pretext he went over his one allotted minute!)
https://www.sacbee.com/news/local/education/article277531868.html
I believe all this shit is just gonna fire up the crazies more. Normal people, RISE UP!
And Temecula caves under threat of lawsuit… or DID they? They voted yes on the “curriculum” but are somehow gonna omit Milk, and KoMORONsky, announcing defiantly to Governor Newsom that he is a “Sovereign Citizen,” swears that when these textbooks come to Temecula’s shipping and receiving, he’s gonna order that they be shipped right back!
Confusing, can someone explain? OR… Maybe KoMORONsky is spouting the Ahab talk of someone who lost his majority.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jul/22/california-school-district-adopts-curriculum-lgbtq-figures
Wow Vern, I always liked you but I guess no one bats a thousand.
As for the dangerous civil rights problem, why not have anorexia affirming care then? After all, if you believe something about yourself it’s Your Truth™ and who is anyone to say a 78 pound 15 year old girl (whatever that is) shouldn’t be prescirbed diet pills of have a lap band installed. You know, because she’s ‘fat’. Oh, and don’t tell their parents because F them, and rights or something.
Just think of the great strides in mental health we’ve achieved by turning psychiatric disorders into ‘genders’ and ‘lifestyles’ and ‘civil rights’. By the way, I’m the Emperor of France.
Normal people, indeed.
What’s the death or serious injury rate (excluding being beaten by others) of being trans vs. being anorexic?
Being trans is not inherently life- and health-threatening. Anorexia is. Gender dysphoria is not a mental illness. Anorexia is.
Nice to know that you’re as empathetic as ever. Maybe there’s a cure for that?
“Gender dysphoria is not a mental illness”
Not only is it a mental illness, believing it isn’t is a mental illness.
Never change. Greg.
Thanks, I won’t change, you stupid cowardly ignorant bigoted asshole.
Gender dysphoria is a mental condition caused by the mismatch between one’s gender assigned at birth and one’s sense of one’s actual gender. It is recognized and diagnosed, but not diagnosed as an mental illness. It may lead to such conditions such as an anxiety disorder — more likely if left untreated after puberty than if treated — but it is not in and of itself a mental illness. One may argue that the illness is not in the person but in the prejudice and intolerance in the world around them if they try to align their apparent gender to their sense of self.
Perhaps read up on something before you comment; it’s a pretty easy search. Likely even for you.
“Gender assigned at birth”
You can identify the sex of a fetus at twelve weeks. You can identify the sex of skeletal remains tens if not hundreds of thousands of years later, without knowing a thing about how that person felt about themselves.
Discuss.
* and yes, if you notice I said sex instead of ‘gender’, you are correct, because sex is real and gender in this use case is nonsense; assigning (see what I did there) a title to whichever infinite combination of proclivities that particular individual has. It’s like Pokémon, a paracosm (that means highly detailed fantasy world, for the stupid), minus the humor.
Essayli takes swipe at Min.
https://www.presstelegram.com/2023/07/27/bill-essayli-calls-attention-to-drunk-pols/amp/
Beware of the Bonta.
https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-08-04/bonta-opens-investigation-into-chino-valley-school-district-policy-to-notify-parents-about-lgbtq-students
Temecula school board sued over critical race theory.
https://www.pressenterprise.com/2023/08/02/temecula-school-board-sued-for-critical-race-theory-ban/
The teaching materials that bother some Temecula board members.
https://www.ocregister.com/2023/08/04/heres-whats-in-the-new-temecula-curriculum-that-concerns-some-board-members/
Good news from Temecula: https://edsource.org/2023/one-temecula-valley-pac-submits-5236-signatures-for-joseph-komrosky-recall/701925
Local normal people have submitted MORE-THAN-ENOUGH signatures to put the recall of the horrific Joseph “Why even mention that pedophile” Komrosky onto the spring ballot. Just removing him will flip the majority back to sanity, but it’s also apparent that another board lunatic, Danny Gonzalez, is leaving town.
So that’s all good, and there’s more good news from the Orange USD, but as this is an OC blog, I’ll be writing a whole story about that!