.
.
.
[Note: this was originally published on 3/9; republished 3/20.]
Of the local races that we actually cared much about Tuesday (and perhaps I am using the royal “we,” I’m no longer sure) most are disappointing at this point. But we have long memories, nearly ancestral ones, of California election results changing dramatically over the first week of counting – usually in the favor of Democrats, and progressives. So here are the ones we’re holding out hope for, as of Wednesday morning while there are still “zero precincts reporting,” and we’ll keep going back to OCvote every 5 pm to see if these races radically transform – it’s happened before!
As of 3/20, the counting in OC is complete. (It continues in LA, but those results are highly unlikely to change.) So here’s how these races of interest ended up:
- Bernie beat Biden in OC by 8.8%. Too bad that’s not letter reflected in the DPOC CC results.
- AD-72: Diedre Nguyen beat Tyler Diep by 832 votes, or 0.7%, and will face Janet Nguyen, who had 33.8%, in a winnable runoff!
- CA-39: Young Kim and Gil Cisneros proceed to the runoff, while Steve Cox is out. Kim had 50.36% in OC to Cisneros’s 44.65%, but overall (with more votes to come from LA, where Cisneros leads with 53.6 to 41.8%, the current overall result of 48.4% to 46.8% will continue to shift towards Gil.
- SD-29: Ling-Ling Chang, with 47.5% overall (52.3% in OC) will face Josh Newman, with 33.5% overall (34.6% in OC.) Because LA votes are still coming in — Chang leads Newman there by 41.6% to 31.3% — that overall margin will tighten a little. The third candidate, Joseph Cho, was a Democrat from LA County, and his 26.1% there (19.0% overall) will largely go to Newman. Combine that with the bluer electorate in November and this looks like a tight race, probably slightly favoring Josh.
- SD-37: John Moorlach, with 47.3% of the vote, will face a runoff with Dave Min, who defeated Katrina Foley with 28.0% of the vote to her 24.7%.
- SUPE 1: Andrew Do got 42.3% of the vote and will face Sergio Contreras, who got 22.4%, Miguel Pulido trailed Contreras by 2,106 votes, with 20.2%. Kim Berniece Nguyen got 15%.
- SUPE 3: With 52.34%, Don Wagner beat Ashleigh Aitken with 47.66%.
- CBOE 3: Ken Williams beat Andy Thorburn by 59.2% to 40.8%.
- CBOE 4: Tim Shaw won with 33.1%, Vicki Calhoun finished 6,216 votes behind him with 27,2%, Paulette Chaffee trailed with 22.1%. Jordan Brandman finished last with 17.6%.
UPDATE Day 2: With “100% of precincts” reporting, the races we care about have barely budged, although in the right way. The registrar says they still have 166,107 ballots left to count; apparently they counted 21,461 today – Wednesday – so maybe whatever movement we saw today we could multiply by 9?
UPDATE Day 4 (Friday, 5pm) Now 127,867 ballots left to count. 694 of those are vote-by-mail; 32,689 of those are from ballot drop-boxes; 12,624 are “eligible vote-by-mail ballots received after Election Day; and 9,771 are “Conditional Voter Registration.” Let’s see how what’s been counted has changed things…
UPDATE Saturday (next one Monday at 5) 126,109 ballots left to count, which means they did 1,763 today – this is going slow! The vast majority of the ballots remaining now are 91,707 vote-by-mail returned at vote centers (that would include mine & Donna’s) and 24,047 left in drop boxes. I’ll redo the following in the order of HOPEFULNESS, and maybe get rid of a couple hopeless ones, like Thorburn v. Williams.
And MONDAY – 102,610 votes left. At this rate it may be 4 more days, and whatever progress we see here we could expect to multiply it fourfold MAYBE (And the only progress is in Diedre catching up with Tyler right now.)
UPDATE Sunday 3/8 (by Greg) I don’t want to horn in on Vern’s post, but this is a good day to check the OC races that are shared with other counties, here relying on the Secretary of State’s site:
CA-38: Linda Sanchez leads with 77.5% of the vote over Michael Tolar. This is the last update you’ll get on this.
CA-39: with 66,634 votes (49.9%), Young Kim leads incumbent Gil Cisneros, who had 60,518 (45.3%). Lefty independent Steve Cox had 6,459 (4.8%) and did not make the runoff. This is actually a pretty good result for Gil, given that turnout will greatly increase during the November election; he’s well within the “Quirk-Silva range” of being favored before a larger electorate. But it will take work.
CA-47: Al Lowenthal, with 48,277 votes (43.0%) will be in a runoff against John Briscoe, who got 20,924 (18.6%). Republican Amy Phan West got 15.3%, Democrat Peter Mathews got 10.1%, and Jalen Dupree McLoud (8.8%) and Sou Moua (4.1%) might want to consider a more entry-level race next time.
CA-49: Mile Levin got 90,433 votes (54.6%) against Brian Maryott’s 75,170 (45.4%). Maryott won by 9.4% in OC and Levin by 15.8% in the much larger (7/9 of Levin’s votes and 2/3 of Maryott’s San Diego County haul.
SD-29: This one is of some concern for Democrats, despite that the two Dems combines got a plurality of the votes. Overall, Ling Ling Chang 79.054 (48.8%), Josh Newman got 53.663 (33.1%), and Joseph Cho won 28,375 (18.1%). Josh will do better in November — he seemed to reserve his forces this winter, putting out far fewer signs than did Cho — and if Cho’s voters vote policies rather than closest ethnicity Josh should get the brunt of them as well.
In Los Angeles County, Chang received 43.3%, Newman 31.3%, and Cho 25.2%.
In Orange County, Chang received 49.2%, Newman 34.0%, and Cho 16.8%.
In Chino Hills, Chang received 53.3%,
AD-55: The third race in North OC’s Tri-Counties area mirrors the overlapping Senate race. Overall, Phillip Chen got 50,768 votes (57.8%), Andrew Rodriguez got 37,137 (42.2%). In LA/OC/Chino Hills, respectively, Chen’s numbers were 10,409 (48.4%), 32,936 (61.7%), and 7,423 (57.2%). The respective numbers for Rodriguez were 11,110 (51.6%), 20,476 (38.3%), and 5,551 (42.8%). It’s Yorba Linda’s district, the rest of us just live here. But this is pretty good for a primary.
UPDATE Day 2: Diedre has moved up a little these 24 hours, THIS could actually happen. To catch up with Tyler she has to make up 2.56%, or 1,975 votes. THEN and only then can we have the Battle of the Female Nguyens!
UPDATE Day 3: This is the only noticeable movement we see on Thursday (when the registrar only counted 378 votes) – Diedre is now only 559 votes behind Tyler – 1.54%!
Day 4: Slow progress for Diedre who’s now behind Tyler by 1.2% (1,050 votes) for the chance to take on Janet in November. My friends in Little Saigon think she will pull this off. Hopeful-face emoticon. And it’s time to mention how much easier this would be if it weren’t for phony Dem candidate Bijan Mohseni taking 13,135 votes (14.8%) while being funded by Farrah-appointed Irvine Mayor Pro-tem and Republican snake Michael Carroll – a story I’ll be writing over the weekend. ANGRY-FACE EMOTICON.
And update Saturday – that Diedre is really nipping at Tyler’s heels – 309 votes behind, or 0.31%! And remember, 126,109 votes left to count! MONDAY – gap is narrowing even more, she’s only 291 behind, or 0.29%.
[Greg here, at 8:20 p.m., 3/12. Diedre is now 647 votes ahead of Diep. With 9,254 votes left in the entire county, most of them conditional registrations, her making the runoff against Janet Nguyen is a mortal lock. May the best Nguyen win! (P.S., and that ain’t Janet!)
[Diedre’s now up by 778, with the 3/13 results. That’s 0.67 percent — and beyond a reasonable recount range. But it’s Tyler’s money if he wants to try! Election workers are happy to get more work!]
[Diedre was at 817 on Saturday 3/14; Monday 3/16 has her at 825. Monday 3/17, 14 more makes 839. Diedre? You can stop beating up on Tyler now; he’s done. Diedre? Diedre?]
OC Board of Education District 4. We are pleasantly surprised to see our favorite, Dr. Vicki Calhoun, not only ahead of the two crooked Democrats Paulette and Jordan (Jordan is WAY behind), but only 7 points from the favored, charter-loving Republican Tim Shaw. Tim 34, Vicki 27, Paulette 23, Jordan 17, and Tim’s lead over Vicki shrunk from 10 to 7 points overnight. Wow, could Vicki pull this out despite everything? And she didn’t even run a campaign, mainly due to her mother’s death. She would be a great Board of Education trustee. Keep checking back!
UPDATE Day 2: Also hasn’t moved these 24 hours. Also Disheartening. But unlike Andy, Vicki is only 4,070 votes behind Tim – that could happen this week!
Day 4: Also hasn’t moved much – Vicki is at 26.4% to Tim’s 33.9%, 5657 votes behind him as all four candidates receive more votes. Saturday pretty much the same, but like we said, 126,109 still left to count. Monday she has crawled up to 26.47%.
3/12: [Greg here] Tim Shaw, 33.37%; Vicki Calhoun, 26.90%; Paulette Chaffee, 22.14%; Jordan Brandman, 17.59%. It’s over, thanks to Jordan. Teachers‘ unions, I have to tell you a hard truth: this is your fault. You listened to the values-free guy who has been chumming up to you rather than to us observers, both in thus publication and in the party, who KNOW how unpopular he is — and he didn’t do much of anything once he got your endorsement, which he knew would hand the election to charter schools’ candidate. You need to think about WHY this happened and make sure that it never happens again. One of the other two candidates, likely Calhoun, would have won without Jordan in the race.
Supervisor District 1. It’s not surprising to see Republican Andrew Do get the most votes, with three Dems running against him – if he managed to break 50% that would mean the race was over. But it doesn’t look that way – he went from 47% to 45% overnight – so the question is which of the three Dems will make it to face him in November – corrupt SA Mayor Pulido, “wanting” Westminster Councilman Contreras, or our favorite, GG councilwoman Kim Bernice Nguyen. Unfortunately Kim is way behind as of now, at 14%, but we still hold out hope for a BERNICE MIRACLE. The race for #2 spot has been switching back and forth between Sergio and Miguel, with Sergio now ahead by a point at 21%. (I might actually prefer Do in that case – at least he’s more honest than either Miguel or Sergio.)
UPDATE Day 2: Kim has inched up to 14.9%; if she will be Do’s challenger she’ll have to pass Miguel and Sergio, who are at 19.77 and 20.59 respectively. She needs to get about 3559 votes to catch up with the guys. At least we can be sure that Do, at 44.94%, will have to face an opponent in November.
Day 4: Kim hasn’t really moved, sad-face emoticon, and Sergio is still ahead of Miguel for second place behind Do. Sergio 20.9%, Miguel 19.6%, Kim still 14.9%. She is now 4212 votes behind Sergio. And Saturday… She’s inched up to 15.1% to Sergio’s 21.1% – a 4544-vote gap. Lots left to count! MONDAY she’s inched up to 15% behind Sergio’s 21.37%.
[Greg here on 3/12: With 22.39%. Sergio Contreras has almost certainly defeated Miguel Pulido, who got 20.24% of the vote. The bad news: Andrew Do got almost exactly as many as both of them combines. The good new: the fourth candidate, Kim Berniece Nguyen, got almost 15% of the vote, so unless Pulido sells out to Do (and what does he have to sell?), the Dems got about 55% combined — and almost always do better in general elections.
Supervisor District 4. This 2-person race will be over when they’re done counting votes, and right now Democrat Ashleigh Aitken is at 46% against Don Wagner’s 54%. She stole 3% from him over the course of the night, so things are heading in Ashleigh’s direction. I know some Democrats don’t care too much about this race, but I hope Ashleigh pulls it out – not least because the grotesque dishonest last-minute attacks on her from Don and his developer buddies should not be rewarded.
UPDATE Day 2: This race hasn’t really moved since last night, with Ashleigh still 8.4% (7871 votes) behind “Spanky.” Not hopeful.
Day 4: The gap has narrowed only microscopically, with Ashleigh 7.8% (8352 votes) behind “Spanky.” SATURDAY it’s narrowed a little more – Ashleigh is 7.1% (8343 votes) behind. And like I keep saying, 126,109 votes still out there. MONDAY the gap’s narrowed to 6.6%. Ashleigh’s 8,383 votes behind, with 102,610 left to count.
[Greg here on 3/12: Wagner leads by 52.60% to 47.40%, 7,803 votes. There aren’t even that many votes left in this district. Anaheim City Council, Ashleigh. We need you.]
State Senate District 34 – the question here is who will be the Democrat to take on The Moorlach? I’ve been rooting for Katrina Foley over Dave Min just because I know and think highly of her, and I think she could have some great debates with John. (Which would help me decide in November – John has a lot of good points for a Republican.) Right now Dave is one point above Katrina, we’ll keep checking back to see how that shakes out.
UPDATE Day 2: Also hasn’t moved since last night. Whatever. Dave is reportedly a nice smart guy and Katrina’s a good mayor.
Day 4: Unchanged – Dave 3804 votes ahead, Katrina 1.9% behind. SATURDAY – Gap has WIDENED to Katrina’s detriment – 2.4% or 5118 votes. MONDAY the gap has widened more – Katrina 2.7% behind.
Min has 27.86%, Foley has 24.45%. This one is over.
OC Board of Education District 3. Wow, right now good Democrat Andy Thorburn is WAY behind scalp-farming troglodyte Ken Williams, 61-39 (It shifted two points in Andy’s favor overnight.) I was expecting this to be closer; Andy spent a lot of money and a couple dozen of us have been working hard on this campaign for months. On the other hand, going by my experience last night… almost all of Andy’s supporters I talked to had just voted in the last couple days or were actually at the polls right then. So.. we’ll see?
UPDATE Day 2: Also hasn’t moved these 24 hours. Disheartening. Right now Andy would have to make up over 21,000 votes which seems very improbable with 166,000 left to count countywide.
Day 4: This has stayed pretty much the same from Day 1 – Ken at 60.8% and Andy at 39.2%. Saturday Andy’s up to 39.5%. Maybe he’ll make it to 40%, that would be a little less sad. 126,109 votes still out, and Ken is ahead by 25,304. Monday … well, at least Andy’s getting real close to 40 – he’s at 39.86%.
[Greg here on 3/12: 59.30% for Ken Williams, 40.7% for Andy. This is an terribly sad result.]
[Greg here in 3/14: Diedre up by 827 over Tyler. No one’s catching up with Tim Shaw or Ken Williams. Contreras safely ahead of Pulido for the runoff against Do. Ashleigh never caught up with Wagner.
Finally, in the cross-county line races, starting with SD-29, and bearing in mind that LA county votes are nowhere near completely counted (and I think the same is true for SD):
Joseph Cho (Party Preference: DEM) | 38,524 |
18.8%
|
|
Josh Newman (Party Pref: DEM) | 68,478 | 33.5% | |
*Ling Ling Chang (Party Pref: REP) | 97,397 | 47.7% |
And AD-55 (which will probably get even closer when LA’s in):
Andrew E. Rodriguez
(Party Pref: DEM)
|
48,800 |
43.4%
|
|
*Phillip Chen
(Party Preference: REP)
|
63,549 | 56.6% |
And CA-39, where LA votes may put Gil ahead in the primary, which underestimates how he’ll likely do in the runoff!
Gil Cisneros
(Party Pref: DEM)
|
78,902 |
46.6%
|
|
Young Kim
(Party Pref: REP)
|
82,391
|
48.6% | |
Steve Cox
(Party Pref: NPP)
|
8,064
|
4.8% |
And CA-47, where the question is “who loses to Al Lowenthal?” The answer, though it was close, is John Briscoe:
*Alan Lowenthal
(Party Pref: DEM)
|
67,390 |
45.0%
|
|
Peter Mathews
(Party Pref: DEM)
|
16,032 | 10.7% | |
Jalen Dupree McLeod
(Party Pref: DEM)
|
12,516 |
8.4%
|
|
John Briscoe
(Party Pref: REP)
|
25,905 | 17.3% | |
Sou Moua
(Party Pref: REP)
|
5,643 | 3.8% | |
Amy Phan West
(Party Pref: REP)
|
22,209 | 14.8% |
And last and least, CA-49:
Mike Levin
(Party Pref: DEM)
|
115,588 |
55.6%
|
|
Brian Maryott
(Party Pref: REP)
|
92,242 | 44.4% |
Levin would be the favorite in November even if the numbers were reversed.
Next update on these races will be at 5pm Thursday!
In other news, we’re happy to report OC Board of Education central-county trustee Beckie Gomez, a solid progressive, has sailed to re-election!
Mission Viejo Mayor Greg Raths is going to be the Republican to take on Congresswoman Katie Porter – Diamond will be pleased about that, but if he turns out to be the one who can beat Batgirl *I* sure won’t be.
Harley Rouda’s Republican opponent, unsurprisingly, will be Michelle Steel.
As Diamond reminds us, the Newman – Ling-Ling race and the Cisneros – Young Kim race look better for the Democrats when you include the neighboring counties (LA and San Bernardino) that are included in those districts.
And it looks like the lame-ass government-crippling Measure A is up too far to be reversed – Democrats should have fought it harder.
Any other insights are welcome in the comments section – I’ll be updating this at 5pm today and for the near future.
How could you even consider anyone against John Moorlach? For shame, Vern! For shame!
I wanna hear a good debate between him and Katrina. And I want to question her on all the things he’s good on, police oversight, etc. Right now I’m tending to want to keep our best Republican. Although I do notice he endorses some real doozies, like Ken Williams.
I could consider it.
I watched Moorlach pretty closely for 3 three years. He accomplished almost nothing as a County Supervisor because he can’t separate practical problems from emotional, or worse, Biblical, responses. When the sun sets on the day John believes in ideas instead of empirical solutions. And the ideas are actually pretty trite.
One of his fave phrases is “if you can’t measure it, you can’t manage it” a cliche that actually reflects a good bit of truth; but he almost never followed his own advice because he was so enamored with notions of helping “widows and orphans,” and because of his devoted belief in the fiction of the “County family.”
*DZ…Dead wrong….AGAIN? Oh my, Pappa John does more before you get up in the morning than you do all day. We have had our disagreements with Pappa John over the years, but he is right about 90% of the time. Not bad for an elected in any category.
“One of his fave phrases is “if you can’t measure it, you can’t manage it” a cliche that actually reflects a good bit of truth; but he almost never followed his own advice because he was so enamored with notions of helping “widows and orphans,” and because of his devoted belief in the fiction of the “County family.””
I’ve been trying hard to let that paragraph make me dislike him.
It’s … not … working …
I don’t know whether you read my piece posted last night, but these are OC ONLY results, so results from CA-39, CA-47, CA-49, SD-29, and AD-55 will be incomplete until merged with those of other counties — all of whom (except San Bernardino’s Chino Hills) are bluer that O.C. is. So don’t panic about Josh.
Porter has already won in CD 45. Raths won’t come close.
She has not “already won” — though I think she would have been favored over all of the Republican candidates who ran. (Don’t you?) My preference for Raths over the other Republicans (though not over Porter) is that he has enough integrity that he might do the right thing under Trump where others would cower. But he surely won’t (and maybe can’t) do what Porter can do.
Hi Vern! First time reading your blog. Love it! Fingers crossed for Andy. I’m gonna be super bummed if he doesn’t win.
One that caught my eye was Andy Thornburn. He clearly spent a good amount of money on the campaign and had several mailers sent out. I got a few of them. I also saw his signs on the roads. The text size and choice was not the best but overall was ok.
I don’t know if he decided that was the best race for him or someone told him and put him up to it, but it was very ill-fitting and not a good idea. I remember him running in 2018 for Congress against Gil.
His background was running a successful business. During his ads which were well done either highlighted something negative about the other candidate or mentioned he was a teacher at one point and not much else. There really wasn’t much of a sell in terms of his background that would jump out to you and say he’s the right choice. Education is tricky in a way that it does not always correlate either coming into or going out to another office. If I didn’t know Andy prior, nothing that I saw would compel me to jump from a long-term incumbent (who also does not have education experience but has been around forever).
The same situation occurred where Lisa Sparks who is a Dean at Chapman did pretty poorly. Andy would be better off running for city council or mayor depending on where he lives and highlighting his professional business experience. The Congress was a bit ambitious but was probably a better fit than BOE.
Between the 2 races, I have to believe he’s dropped at least $3 million
Andy lives in Villa Park. Ain’t no way he’d win a Council seat there as a Democrat.
His losses are really frustrating, because he really is a good guy. It may be that he could do the most good just funding candidates or starting a PAC than trying to be the one on the dais making decisions. What he’d really do well at is being the DPOC Chair.
does greg have some kind of beef with katie porter?
No, I want her to win. But if she were to lose, I’m glad it would be to Raths rather than to any of the others. Do you follow that?
Unfortunately, today was *not* a good day for Diedre. Yes, she picked up 18 more votes, but it took her way too many cast votes to do it.
On Friday, the total number counted in this race was 97,518. Monday, it was 99,865 — in other words, it took her 2,347 votes to pick up 18. That means that she picked up only 1 vote for every 130 cast. At that rate, she’s need 130 x 292 = 37,960 votes to win. There won’t be that many left. (I’ll explain the bright side further down.)
Part of the problem is that Janet and Bijan combined won 50% of those votes — and will likely to continue to do so. Another problem is that many of those 8,527 provisionals won’t count for various legitimate reasons, so let’s cut that down to 4,550, And the biggest problem is that when you look at those 102,690 votes left to count, that’s countywide; you’d expect only 2/13 (or 1/6.5, given that AD-55 is a half-district) to be in AD-72. (As I recall, though, it would be a little higher given that AD-69 has a lower turnout. Still.) So, for example, you’d expect only 700 of those provisionals to end up in AD-72.
Once we toss out 3,973 provisionals to get down to 4550, we have (102,610 – 3973 =) 98,637 uncounted votes left in the county. AD-72 might get 16% of them (adjusting for AD-69) — that’s 15,788. At this rate, she’d pick up (15,788/130 =) about 121.5 votes.
But if you look over at my “What’s Left to Vote” post, you’d see that there’s a good reason to be more optimistic. She’s not likely to pick up votes at only this rate. She had a bad day today because today was when the drop box vote came. Janet has engaged in ballot harvesting — and, many allege, cheating such as forging the signatures of those in nursing homes. Would her people take those to a vote center or drop them in the mail? My guess is that they’d use drop boxes. If so. then Diedre’s rate — which as I recall was much better before — will be much better again. Late deciders — and most of what’s left is “VBM ballots returned at vote centers” (which Janet has reportedly used in polls in the past, before the drop-off boxes that don’t require human contact, i.e., witnesses) — and provisionals, which may skew more towards Diedre.
A much better analysis than this would be possible by checking Statements of the Vote on various days and see how Diedre did on various days and how much of the county vote does come in to AD-72. If I had more time, I’d do that — but anyone else can step up and volunteer to do it themselves! It’s all at the ROV site.
Are you able to determine how many votres are left to count in dierdres district?
No, but I’m betting that by 5 she’s got Tyler in her rear view mirror, and there won’t be any turning back.
Next target JANET!
“Next target JANET!”
With Tyler’s help. Only Diedre can bring peace with a new generation of Viet political leadership.
Wow diedre passed diep by 8 votes
208. And she’ll probably get some more tomorrow.